John Ross 1818 – 1821 (not installed)

John Rankin 1822 - 1844

Lysander Kelsey 1845 – 1846

J.R. Gibson 1846 – 1852

Williams Lumsden 1853 – 1855

William Perkins 1856 – 1858

David Gould 1858 – 1865

Daniel E. Bierce 1866 – 1873

David H. Hamilton 1873 – 1879

J.M. Cockins 1880 – 1884

W.N. Torrence 1884 – 1886

William Best 1892 – 1895

E.W. Thompson 1896 – 1901

J.P. Green 1901 – 1905

J.U. Brown 1906 – 1907

J.B. Meacham 1907 – 1910

J.C. Francis 1912 – 1915

Thomas Patterson, Jr. 1915 – 1917

A.L. South 1918 – 1920

Thomas Patterson, Jr. 1920 – 1926

W.W. Scafe 1927 – 1930

Claude Saunders 1931 – 1937

T. Gordon Holmes 1937 – 1943

Irven E. Shudlick 1944 – 1952

Robert Edward Johnson 1952 – 1956

John L. Hunt 1956 – 1958

Alonza Millard Alexander 1958 – 1962

Donald Bruce Newroth 1962 – 1965

Brian R. Tansey 1966 – 1970

Thomas G. Holmes 1971 – 1972

James Chain 1974 – 1978

David Choate 1979 – 1984 (student and pastor)

C. Paul Reinhart 1986 – 1987

Harold Russell 1988 – 1989 (interim)

Joseph J. Slayblack, Jr. 1989 – 1989 (student supply)

Christine Woods-Henderson 1989 – 1993

Scott Gepford 1993 – 1994 (student intern)

Nancy Bassett 1996 – 2003

James R. Rawlings 2003 – 2008 (Methodist Lay Pastor)

Wayne L. Reveal 2008 –

Charles Nyland 2019-